Get In Touch With Us!
Full Tactical Comparison
Deep-dive into the operational specifications of both firms.
Prop Firm
Lucid Trading
TradeDay
Firm Overview
| Review score | ★ 4.8 / 5 | ★ 4.6 / 5 |
| CEO | AJ Campanella | James Thorpe |
| Years in operation | 1+ years | 6+ years |
| Founded | April 2025 | 2020 |
Evaluation Details These figures reflect the cheapest evaluation plan available from each firm.
| Account Sizes |
$25,000$50,000$100,000$150,000 |
$50,000$100,000$150,000 |
| Billing period | One Time | Month |
| Discount | ❎ | PIP |
| Instant Accounts | ❎ | |
| DLL | ❎ | |
| Activation Fee | ❎ |
Rules and Policies
| News trading | ❎ | Not Allowed. No Trades 2 Mins. before/after News |
| Swing accounts | ❎ | Not Allowed |
| Consistency rules | ❎ | 30% In Eval Only. None on Funded. |
| Commissions | ❎ | Platform-dependent |
| Firm rules | ❎ |
|
Payments and Operations
| Profit split | ❎ | 80-95% |
| Payment methods | Credit/Debit Card | Credit/Debit Card / PayPal |
| Payout methods | Bank Transfer | Rise |
| Platforms |
            |
 |
| Support | Discord / Email / Live Chat | Discord / Email / Live Chat |
Trust and Access
| KYC | ❎ | After Passing Eval |
| Restricted countries | Yes | Yes |
| Changelog | ❎ | ❎ |
Evaluation Comparison Module
The industry standard benchmark. Which firm offers the better 50,000 unit plan today?
Lucid Trading
PRO
Best for traders who want daily loss to increase with profits and maximise profits.
FLEX
For trades who want no daily loss limit and no consistency in the funded phase.
DIRECT
Skip the evaluation and trade on the Sim-Funded immediately.
TradeDay
INTRADAY TRAIL
Best for active traders who want the a lower cost in exchange for intraday drawdown.
EOD TRAIL
Best for traders who prefer end of day drawdown.
STATIC
For traders willing to pay more for a drawdown that does not trail.
Critical Rule Comparison
Consistency
Lucid
—
TradeDay
30% In Eval Only. None on Funded.
News Trading
Lucid
—
TradeDay
Not Allowed. No Trades 2 Mins. before/after News
Swing Trading
Lucid
—
TradeDay
Not Allowed
KYC & Access
Lucid
—
TradeDay
After Passing Eval
Payout policy
Lucid
—
TradeDay
All Accounts – Clear Buffer Zone
Commissions
Lucid
—
TradeDay
Platform-dependent
Payouts and Costs These figures reflect the cheapest evaluation plan available from each firm.
Compare how you get paid and what it costs.
| COMPARE |
Lucid Trading
|
TradeDay
|
|---|---|---|
| Profit Split | 90% | 80% to $50k | 90% $50k - $100k | 95% >$100k |
| Payout Frequency | 5 Trading Days w/ Min. Profit | After Attaining Buffer Zone |
| Evaluation Price | $60 / one time | $100 / month |
| Billing Period | One Time | Month |
| Payout Methods | Bank Transfer | Rise |
| Payment Methods | Credit/Debit Card | Credit/Debit Card / PayPal |
Platforms, Support, and Operations
| COMPARE |
Lucid Trading
|
TradeDay
|
|---|---|---|
| Platforms |
|
|
| Support Channels |
|
|
| KYC | N/A |
Required
After Passing Eval |
Restricted Countries
Lucid Trading
TradeDay
Both
Lucid Trading
71 countries
Afghanistan
Albania
Belize
Algeria
Angola
Bahamas
Barbados
Belarus
Bulgaria
Burkina Faso
Myanmar
Botswana
Burundi
Cambodia
Central African Republic
Ivory Coast
Ukraine
Cuba
Republic of the Congo
DR Congo
Ukraine
Ecuador
Ethiopia
Ghana
Guinea
Haiti
Iceland
Indonesia
Iraq
Jamaica
Kenya
Ukraine
Kosovo
Lebanon
Liberia
Libya
Ukraine
Mali
Mauritius
Mongolia
Montenegro
Mozambique
Namibia
Nicaragua
Nigeria
North Macedonia
Pakistan
Panama
Papua New Guinea
Philippines
Senegal
Serbia
Russia
Ukraine
Slovenia
Somalia
South Africa
South Sudan
Sri Lanka
Sudan
Seychelles
Tanzania
Turkey
Trinidad and Tobago
Tunisia
Uganda
Ukraine
Vietnam
Venezuela
Yemen
Zimbabwe
TradeDay
79 countries
Afghanistan
Albania
Algeria
Angola
Barbados
Belarus
British Virgin Islands
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Botswana
Bulgaria
Burkina Faso
Burundi
Cameroon
Cayman Islands
Central African Republic
Ivory Coast
Ukraine
Croatia
Cuba
North Korea
DR Congo
Ecuador
Ethiopia
Ghana
Gibraltar
Guam
Guyana
Haiti
Iceland
Indonesia
Iran
Iraq
Jamaica
Jordan
Kosovo
Laos
Lebanon
Liberia
Libya
North Macedonia
Mali
Malta
Mauritius
Monaco
Mongolia
Montenegro
Morocco
Mozambique
Myanmar
Namibia
Nepal
Nicaragua
Nigeria
Pakistan
Panama
Papua New Guinea
Philippines
Puerto Rico
Romania
Russia
Senegal
Serbia
Slovenia
Somalia
South Africa
South Sudan
Sri Lanka
Sudan
Syria
Tanzania
Trinidad and Tobago
Tunisia
Uganda
Ukraine
U.S. Virgin Islands
Venezuela
Vietnam
Yemen
Zimbabwe
Featured Tools
Recommendation Tool
Helps traders quickly find the prop firm that best matches their trading style and goals by giving personalized suggestions.
Try Our Recommendation Tool Now
Evaluation Calculator
Helps you understand what it takes to pass a prop firm evaluation by showing key requirements like profit targets and drawdown limits.
Try Our Evaluation Calculator Now
